The German by Lee Thomas

5 Stars

The German The German by Lee Thomas had been on my reading list since its release by Lethe Press in March 2011. I was finally able to get to it in late 2012 and read it in virtually one sitting. As a long-time reader of the suspense/thriller and horror fiction, over the years I’ve read my share of both well-written and utterly forgettable stories in these sub-genres. However, it’s been a long while since I’ve read a story of this calibre of excellence.


“Over the years I had convinced myself that brutality required motive, but this is a fool’s deceit. Cruelty is the motive; religion and politics and resources are simply the cloth man weaves to curtain his desires for violence. All ideologies are inherently wrong. None have worked. None have emerged as dominant to the point of suppressing all others, and if this is true – if time has not proven a thing irrefutable – then a thing is a lie. Religion and politics encourage violence so that the meek will proudly throw away breath and flesh because their rot fertilizes fat succulent flora. Men thrive in these gardens of atrocity, proudly tending the blossoms, convinced that the clusters of lovely, vibrant petals – their gods, their governments, their belief in an unquestionable right to destroy all that does not resemble them – are worth the blood and the meat that feed the stalks.”

The story takes place in 1944 at the height of the Second World War. The setting is small town Barnard, Texas, where, as elsewhere in America, the war effort is a matter of daily life, patriotism is rife, there are good guys and bad guys and the world is black and white. The town has a sizeable ex-patriot German population, and like most immigrant groups they are hard working, try to fit in and have achieved a level of co-existence with their non-German neighbours. However, already a suspect group due to Hitler and the Nazis, their fragile peace is shattered when a series of calculated and gruesome murders of the town’s young men and boys begin to take place. The only clues the killer leaves behind are painted snuffboxes containing notes written in German.

Inevitably the town’s inhabitants of German descent become the suspects, and eventually eyes turn to a quiet man with secrets of his own. Ernst Lang fled Germany in 1934. Once a brute, a soldier, a leader of the Nazi party, he has renounced aggression and now embraces a peaceful obscurity only wanting to be left to his solitary pursuits of chair making. But Lang is haunted by an impossible past. He remembers his own execution and the extremes of sex and violence that led to it. He remembers the men he led into battle, the men he seduced, and the men who betrayed him. But are these the memories of a man given a second life, or the delusions of a lunatic?

As community panic of the monster lurking amongst them sets in, the town’s sheriff, Tom Rabbit, and his men are baffled by the crimes and increasingly challenged to apprehend the serial killer, and at the same time ensure that law and order are maintained.

The German is an exquisitely written, chilling suspense thriller with elements of horror fiction that chronicles the unravelling of a town as a result of fear and paranoia. While the central plot is focussed on the mystery of the serial killer that is terrorizing the town by mutilating and killing it’s young men and boys, at the same time Mr. Thomas explores the violence and evil that lurks amongst the townspeople when some succumb to their baser instincts brought about by ignorance, fear and prejudice.

The story is narrated through the voices of three key characters: the first person narration through diary entries of Ernst Lang; the first person narration in retrospective of Tim Randall, the boy who lives across the street from Ernst; and the third person introspection of Sheriff Lamb. The author alternates between these three voices to unfold a page-turning story.

The character of Ernst Lang represents that aspect of the outsider within Barnard. Ernst is far from being a perfect man. He has both perpetrated and experienced brutal violence, but in coming to America has left all that behind and wants to be left alone to go about his life peacefully. His only sins in the eyes of the townspeople are that he is German and gay.

Tim Randall is a young man who lives with his mother while his father is overseas fighting the “Krauts”. As Ernst’s neighbour, Tim is both fascinated by and apprehensive of the man, but his curiosity wins out and he forms a friendship of sorts with him. Ernst even tries to educate Tim and his best friend Bum against prejudice and hate. But when Tim and Bum spy on Ernst and discover him having sex with another man Tim becomes convinced that Ernst is the killer. This, coupled with Tim’s grief and fear over his father, who is declared missing in action, motivate him to join forces with some unsavoury town elements bent on taking matters into their own hands and making Ernst the scapegoat.

There are two lone voices of reason and compassion in this story, those of Sheriff Lamb and Bum. Sheriff Lamb is fundamentally a decent and fair man. Although he is also a product of his environment in respect of his views on homosexuality, his sense of justice dictates that he condemn no man without evidence or because he is gay. He faces several challenges both in solving the ghastly murders and in keeping at bay the mounting sense of vigilantism within Barnard. While no part of the story is written from the perspective of Bum, the character’s strong voice comes through his interactions with Tim and his reactions to Tim’s plans and actions. In many respects Bum serves as Tim’s conscience attempting to convince him to not judge without cause and to not join in the violence against Ernst.

The author’s rich descriptions capture the insular existence of Barnard, Texas, and the story exudes an atmosphere of stifling oppression and extreme tension where fear and paranoia have completely taken over. The violence is graphic and gruesome not only in respect of the murders but also in terms of what the townspeople are capable of perpetrating. The elements of the supernatural further heighten the horror and suspense in this story. The opening scene in which Ernst experiences his execution is not only macabre and highly disturbing, it also serves as an unbalancing element as to what is real and what is not. This sense of unbalance is carried forward throughout the story in respect of the mystery surrounding the killer, and at story’s end the reader continues to wonder about Ernst.

The German completely blurs the lines of good and evil and there is no black and white in this novel. The underlying theme of this masterfully written story is not only centred on the violence and destruction of one highly disturbed individual, but equally on the potential and capacity for violence and evil that all individuals harbour when ignorance, fear and prejudice take over.

It is no surprise that The German received the 2012 Lambda Literary Award for LGBT Science Fiction, Fantasy and Horror, or that Mr. Thomas was a 2010 Lambda Award finalist in the same category for In The Closet, Under The Bed, and the recipient of the Bram Stoker Award for his debut novel Stained. I am thrilled to have discovered this author and plan on making my way through both his backlist and future releases. The German made my list of the Best in LGBTQ Literature for 2012 and I cannot recommend this book enough.

The German by Lee Thomas is available at Amazon.

Music: I’m Making Believe – The Ink Spots & Ella Fitzgerald

2 thoughts on “The German by Lee Thomas

  1. Awesome review, Indie! You know how I feel about this book. I was blown away by it and became an unabashed Lee Thomas fan after reading it. I’m so glad you loved it. Such a nuanced novel, and that’s his style… wait till you read more of his works!

    • Yep Hils, I haven’t read a suspense/thriller of this calibre in a very long time. I agree a very well nuanced story but also excellent mood-setting. I had so much to say about this book in my review that I forgot to mention how visual this story was for me. I don’t often stray too far from the art form/medium of literature while reading because I enjoy imagining the characters and setting too much, but I read this story as a film. In fact, I think it would make an excellent one! I’ve already purchased Torn, but also want to read through this author’s back list.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s